So, I have sworn to myself that, as a voting member of WorldCon, I must read all the Hugo nominees in time to cast my ballot. As of last night I have completed two of them, which means I am now only monstrously behind instead of insanely behind.
Rollback was the first one I read, and I enjoyed it a good deal: it's one of those books that you slurp up in a few hours like a smoothie. I wanted to love it, because about 1/4 of it was characters having discussions about morality, and seriously, I could read that kind of thing ALL DAY. The problem was, all the characters worked from the unquestioned premise that morality was simply an evolutionary strategy, which in my opinion made the discussions a whole lot less complex and interesting than they could be. Dude, what is the point of discussing morality if you're not going to bring in Platonic archetypes at least?
About the characters, I have only this to say:
( spoilery observations on feminine psychology )Next I read
The Last Colony, which on the whole was a lot of fun. It actually stirred in me nostalgic memories of Timothy Zahn's
Spinneret, which I read as a teenager. They're both about small, struggling Earth colonies that become focal points in galatic politics, but
Spinneret is about creating a colony, deciphering mysterious alien technology, and sticking it to the United Nations, while
Last Colony is about building a colony, deciphering mysterious alien organizations, and sticking it to the Colonial Defense Force that rules all of human space.
My main problem with
Last Colony is that it was far too short, and I don't mean that in an "I wanted more!" way, I mean that in a "SLOW DOWN PLEASE, MR. SCALZI!" sort of way. It seemed that the characters would discover a problem, and then five pages later someone would get an idea, and then the book would jump straight to the characters triumphantly implementing their idea. It made for a fast-paced read, but at times I felt like I was reading an outline of a story, when I really wanted to be living vicariously through the characters.
On the bright side, the main character's wife got to show off her super-mega-warrior skills, and that was pretty awesome. She was my favorite.
(In all honesty, I think I enjoyed
Spinneret more. But that may have been because I read it when I was thirteen, which we all know is the golden age of science fiction.)
(Now that I think about it, I remember that as much as I enjoyed
Spinneret, I was tremendously shocked when I first read it because someone said "damn" every few pages. Oh, my poor lost innocence.)